
When I got my Cigar Aficionado Top Fifty Cigars poster earlier this month, I was a little surprised to see the Puros Indios Viejo 1999 No. 4 Especial ranked among the highest of the Honduran offerings with a rating of 91.
I got three Puros Indios cigars in my Cigar Dave Officer's Club package a few months back. I smoked two of them (the Viejo and the Cuba Aliados) at a party a couple of days later. I remember that they were very good, but I don't remember any specifics. I was smoking outside in very cold weather and was very drunk, so it's not surprising that I don't remember all that much about them 
Still, I had one cigar left from that package: the flagship Puros Indios cigar with the Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper and a blend of Nicaraguan, Brazilian, and Dominican tobaccos for the filler. I decided that I would pop my cigar review cherry with it.
Some cigars have what I call "snob appeal". Puros Indios is not one of those cigars.
They are not a particularly attractive cigar. Their wrappers are not nice, shiny, uniform colors; instead, they have imperfections and almost look like there are twigs under the surface. The label is not anything to write home about either. It's fairly plain: just a big green background with some writing on it.
Contrast this with the Rocky Patel Vintage 1990 cigar I smoked last night: the wrapper is a deep, uniform color and the label is pretty and embossed. The Rocky Patel offering looks amazing.
Even though the Rocky Patel cigar looks great, it kind of sucks. I wasn't impressed with it at all.
The Puros Indios, on the other hand, was excellent.
I often say that I put up with the first third of a cigar -- which is usually not all that exciting to me -- so that I can luxuriate in the last two thirds. But the Puros Indios started delivering excellent flavor to me from the moment I lit it.
If you're a fan of leathery cigars, this one is for you. Smoking this cigar is like smoking an entire cow. It delivers full on flavor from the time you light it until it starts burning your fingers. It finishes off with a little spice. I'm going to buy a box of these as soon as I can. They're really just that good.
And did I mention the price? These sticks can be bought for around $3.00 in my neck of the woods. It's very rare to find a cigar this good at those prices.
So go out and try one of these babies. You may find that, like me, you need to add a box of them to your collection.